Search for books and compare prices on all major online booksellers with one click!

Home  About UsSuggest BookstoreRecommend Us 
    Title/Keywords ISBN  

Are Cops Racist?

AUTHOR: Heather MacDonald
ISBN: 156663489X

Compare Price


HOME--->> Nonfiction --->>Law --->>Law & Current Affairs
 
Law & Current Affairs
         Editorial Review

Are Cops Racist?
- Book Review,
by Heather MacDonald

Amazon.com
"The anti-profiling crusade thrives on an ignorance of policing and a willful blindness to the demographics of crime," writes Heather Mac Donald in this powerful and persuasive examination of racial profiling. Noting that crime has dropped in urban areas over the past decade, she writes that "The last ten years should have been a time of triumph for law enforcement, not an occasion for frenzied cop-bashing." Yet an anti-police stance has pervaded the media in recent years, particularly in The New York Times, she says. This bias, combined with suffocating federal regulations, brought about by both the Clinton and the Bush Justice Departments, threaten to reverse the progress made. It also causes unnecessary friction between police and the public, makes neighborhoods less safe, and even dissuades officers from fighting crime aggressively for fear of being labeled a racist. In instances where the police were clearly in the wrong--most notably the much-publicized and tragic Amadou Diallo shooting--Mac Donald posits that these are isolated cases of poor judgment and failure to follow procedure rather than evidence of systemic racism.

Since much of the profiling issue revolves around highway patrolling, Mac Donald looks closely at the misleading statistics that have been used to back up such practices as tabulating the race of drivers pulled over by the police. Mac Donald punches so many holes in the statistics that it's difficult not to concur with her. She further attacks the "collective fairy tale that all groups commit drug crimes at equal rates," arguing that the police are simply going to where the crime is, not willfully picking on one group while ignoring others. She also does extensive field work: interviewing cops around the country, particularly black officers who find the race-bias argument specious; reporting from urban neighborhoods; and witnessing firsthand how the New York Police Department trains its rookie officers. She also points out that local police are "the first line of defense against terrorism" and makes a particularly compelling argument that racial-profiling should be used as a tool in combating such threats. Overall, this forceful book is sure to arouse controversy--which is exactly the point. --Shawn Carkonen

From Library Journal
MacDonald (The Burden of Bad Ideas) is one of the few authors who attempts to justify current policing methods, arguing that the truth about policing and issues related to race is not known to the general public. She contends that the police should be receiving accolades for all the good work they do; instead, they are constantly attacked by the media (especially the New York Times), which offer unsubstantiated claims that racial profiling is running amok. MacDonald presents a great deal of evidence to debunk this media-driven myth: law-abiding inner-city citizens want a highly visible police presence, black officers pull over the same percentage of minority motorists as do their white counterparts, officers receive many hours of sensitivity and diversity training, and so on. In particular, she takes great exception to what she sees as the New York Times's biased approach to covering police matters, showing, for instance, that they do not report such incidents as police officers capturing gun-wielding felons without firing a shot, as the NYPD has done 155 times since 1995. This book is essential reading for anyone who assumes that racial profiling is an undisputed fact. Highly recommended for collections in criminal justice and the social sciences.Tim Delaney, Canisius Coll., Buffalo, NY Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.

From Booklist
MacDonald asserts that complaints against police of racism and racial profiling undermine the interests of minority victims because blacks are the primary victims of violent crimes and drug activities, the center of the objectionable practice of racial profiling. The author believes that major liberal news media, such as the New York Times, have done a major disservice in misreporting such racially charged incidents as the police killing of Amadou Diallo and the police-station rape of Abner Louima. She dismisses the causes of the Diallo killing as bad police tactics and the Louima rape as overreaction by some officers who take any resistance as a personal assault. She takes issue with statistical analyses on racial profiling that compare police stops of black citizens with their overall proportion of the general population rather than with their proportion of the criminal population. Because her interview subjects are decidedly pro-police, some readers might find this a one-sided view of controversial police practices, but it provides another viewpoint on an important issue. Vernon Ford
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved

American Renaissance
…An antidote to anti-police hysteria...

The New York Sun
Smart and fearless...the best investigative journalist in America....Her argument is simple and clear.

Wall Street Journal
Ms. Mac Donald eviscerates the case against the troopers with careful logic.

Edward A. Flynn, Chief of Police, Arlington County Police Department
Brave and passionate...MacDonald has done America's police the inestimable service of actually learning about them and what they...do.

Shelby Steele
The best and most intrepid journalist writing on racial issues today.... A startling work.

Book Description
How the war againist the police harms Black Americans.

About the Author
Heather Mac Donald, a nonpracticing lawyer, is a John M. Olin Fellow at The Manhattan Institute in New York and a contributing editor of City Journal, the quarterly magazine of urban affairs. Her first book, The Burden of Bad Ideas (also published by Ivan R. Dee), was enthusiastically praised and is now in a sixth printing. She lives and writes in New York City.


Buy from Amazon     Compare Prices



         Book Review

Are Cops Racist?
- Book Reviews,
by Heather MacDonald

Are Cops Racist?

FROM THE PUBLISHER

"The forces of opposition to "racial profiling" threaten to obliterate the crime-fighting gains of the last decade, especially in America's inner cities. This is the message of Heather Mac Donald's new book, in which she brings her special brand of tough and honest journalism to the current war against the police." "The reduction in urban crime, one of the nation's signal policy successes of the 1990s, has benefited black communities even more dramatically than white neighborhoods, she shows. By policing inner cities actively after long neglect, cops have allowed business and civil society to flourish there once more. But attacks on police, centering on charges of police racism and racial profiling, and spearheaded by activists, the press, and even the Justice Department, have slowed this success and threaten to reverse it." Ms. Mac Donald looks at the reality behind the allegations and writes about the black cops you never heard of, the press coverage of policing, and policing strategies across the country. Her iconoclastic findings demolish the prevailing anti-cop orthodoxy.

SYNOPSIS

False charges of "racial profiling" threaten to obliterate the crime-fighting gains of the last decade, especially in America�s inner cities. This is the message of Heather Mac Donald�s new book, in which she brings her special brand of tough and honest journalism to the current war against the police. "The anti-profiling crusade," she charges, "thrives on an ignorance of policing and a willful blindness to the demographics of crime." In careful reports from New York and other major cities across the country, Ms. Mac Donald investigates the workings of the police, the controversy over racial profiling, and the anti-profiling lobby�s harmful effects on black Americans. The reduction in urban crime, one of the nation�s signal policy successes of the 1990s, has benefited black communities even more dramatically than white neighborhoods, she shows. By policing inner cities actively after long neglect, cops have allowed business and civil society to flourish there once more. But attacks on police, centering on false charges of police racism and racial profiling, and spearheaded by activists, the press, and even the Justice Department, have slowed the success and threaten to reverse it. Ms. Mac Donald looks at the reality behind the allegations and writes about the black cops you never heard about, the press coverage of policing, and policing strategies across the country. Her iconoclastic findings demolish the prevailing anti-cop orthodoxy.

FROM THE CRITICS

The Wall Street Journal

Ms. Mac Donald eviscerates the case against the troopers with careful logic.

Commentary

We are lucky to have Heather Mac Donald fighting for the legitimate interests of law enforcement.

New York Sun

Smart and fearless..... the best investigative journalist in America.... .Her argument is simple and clear.

AMERICAN RENAISSANCE

...An antidote to anti-police hysteria...

Library Journal

This book is essential reading. Read all 7 "From The Critics" >

WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING

EDWARD A. FLYNN

Brave and passionate...MacDonald has done America's police the inestimable service of actually learning about them and what they really do. — CHIEF OF POLICE, ARLINGTON COUNTY POLICE DEPARTMENT

The best and most intrepid journalist writing on racial issues today.... A startling work. — SHELBY STEELE


Buy from Barnes & Noble     Compare Prices




HOME  |  Recommend bookstore  |  Rate bookstore  |  Link to us  |  Report bug  |  Contact us
Copyright© 2003 - 2005, PowerBookSearch.com. All Rights Reserved.