Three Billy Goats Gruff
- Book Review,
by Paul Galdone
From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 2 Only the familiar plot of this well-known Norwegian folktale is recognizable in this revision. Gone is the cadence and beauty of G. W. Dasent's translation of Asbjornsen and Moe's text, found in Marcia Brown's version (HBJ, 1957; o.p.). Instead there is language devoid of rhythm and mystery. In addition, unnecessary motivations are ascribed to the characters that serve to explain the reason for their violent actions (the troll is hungry; the big Billy Goat Gruff is angry). These explanations serve only to dilute the power of the story. The full-color illustrations are humorous; the goats walk about on their hind legs, the smallest goat wears a diaper and sucks a pacifier, and the biggest wears a black leather jacket, to reinforce the point that he is tough enough to destroy the troll. The troll is quite scary, and although he does have a nose as long as a poker, his eyes are not as big as saucers; the illustration that introduces the troll does not even show his eyes. A better purchase is Galdone's version (Clarion, 1981) which is well-suited for use with large groups and more closely follows the standard translation. Ellen Fader, Westport Public Library, Conn.Copyright 1987 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
"The large, lively, double-page spreads are sure to win a responsive audience at story hour."
Review
"The large, lively, double-page spreads are sure to win a responsive audience at story hour."
Book Description
The three goat brothers brave the terrible troll in a colorful version of the classic tale.
Card catalog description
Three clever billy goats outwit a big, ugly troll that lives under the bridge they must cross on their way up the mountain.
Buy from Amazon
Compare Prices
|
|
Home
