Gadaffi: The Desert Mystic

From Publishers Weekly
Accused of fostering international terrorism and contravening the stability of the Middle East, Muammar Khadafy has been viewed as a threat by the West for some 20 years. The author of this sprawling, superficial look at Libya and its leader argues that the U.S. has overestimated Khadafy's danger, underestimated his achievements and distorted his character. The Libyan's motives have been "in the main, admirable," according to Tremlett, a British MP during the '70s and '80s. He contends that Colonel Oliver North's anti-Khadafy campaign during the Reagan years produced flimsy or false evidence to use as pretexts for several assassination attempts, most notably the 1986 raid by F-111s when the Americans tried to bomb Khadafy in his bed. The most convincing sections of the book deal with Tremlett's personal impressions of Libya, a country he claims would not survive without the foreign technicians who shore up its fragile infrastructure. Photos. Copyright 1993 Reed Business Information, Inc.

From Kirkus Reviews
A potted revisionist biography of Gaddafi, by Tremlett (Dylan Thomas, 1992). The author's qualifications for this work don't spring out: He speaks neither Arabic nor Italian; has consulted books only in English; and, contrary to the publisher's claim that he ``has been granted extraordinary access to...Gaddafi...and spent months in Libya doing research,'' it would appear from his preface that he spent only a week in Libya and never met its leader. Tremlett's lack of familiarity with Libya is indicated by long quotations from other books, even on subjects like the country's physical appearance. He does offer a short history of Libya; some personal anecdotes; and a repetitious account of the few facts known about Gaddafi. There's also a generally uncritical summation of views on the Libyan leader held by friends and admirers; long extracts from the Green Book, Gaddafi's volume of philosophy; and an inconclusive assessment of Libya's involvement in terrorism, with Tremlett suggesting that most of the major atrocities charged to Libya (the bombing of a Berlin disco; the downing of Pan Am Flight 103) should more properly be laid against Syria or Palestinian terrorists. The general ignorance in the West about Libya and its leader makes some of this detail helpful, and Gaddafi's thought, his actions to redistribute wealth, and his outright condemnation of discrimination against women have previously received too little attention. Tremlett also offers an insightful description of Libya's government--run by 2600 committees in ``a state of constant but thoroughly enjoyable muddle,'' which contributes to a ``diffusion of power [that] means that no one can establish a power base in Libya to challenge [Gaddafi's] authority.'' But the author's conclusions seem questionable--as when he states that Libyans ``are [a]...happy people'' and ``feel free,'' yet notes that ``all Libyans are forbidden to speak to foreigners'' and to criticize Gaddafi's rule. Of some use but, overall, not a book to inspire full confidence as a source. (Photos) -- Copyright ©1993, Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights reserved.


Buy from Amazon     Compare Prices

Accused of fostering international terrorism and contravening the stability of the Middle East, Muammar Khadafy has been viewed as a threat by the West for some 20 years. The author of this sprawling, superficial look at Libya and its leader argues that the U.S. has overestimated Khadafy's danger, underestimated his achievements and distorted his character. The Libyan's motives have been ``in the main, admirable,'' according to Tremlett, a British MP during the '70s and '80s. He contends that Colonel Oliver North's anti-Khadafy campaign during the Reagan years produced flimsy or false evidence to use as pretexts for several assassination attempts, most notably the 1986 raid by F-111s when the Americans tried to bomb Khadafy in his bed. The most convincing sections of the book deal with Tremlett's personal impressions of Libya, a country he claims would not survive without the foreign technicians who shore up its fragile infrastructure. Photos. (Dec.)


Buy from Barnes & Noble     Compare Prices