Big Bang: The Loud Debate over Gun Control

FROM THE CRITICS

VOYA - Kathleen Beck

What restrictions can and should be put on gun ownership? What does the Second Amendment to the Constitution really say? What do other countries do? What role do guns play in societal violence? These are some of the questions considered in this balanced and carefully neutral examination of the gun control issue. The history of gun ownership in America is described, and laws limiting use are outlined. Equal weight is given to the arguments of those for and against gun control. The author does not shy away from controversial issues such as the incidents at Ruby Ridge and Waco. He makes it clear that emotions often play as great a role as facts in determining a person's opinion. Lists of Web sites that were current at the time of publication for organizations on both sides of the debate expose readers to various positions. Other recommended Web sites give more general information. Only in his description of the media's role in promoting gun violence does Lunger allow his objectivity to slip a bit. His cautionary advice to carefully evaluate sources-especially Web sites-for bias is important for young readers. Vocabulary is demanding, but readers will be drawn to the clear print and generous use of white space. Reproductions of photographs are dark, but posters and cartoons add interest. Although few teens are likely to read it straight through, it will prove a valuable, balanced resource for report-writers. Index. Illus. Photos. Charts. Source Notes. Further Reading. VOYA CODES: 4Q 2P M J S (Better than most, marred only by occasional lapses; For the YA with a special interest in the subject; Middle School, defined as grades 6 to 8; Junior High, defined as grades 7 to 9; Senior High, definedas grades 10 to 12). 2002, Twenty-First Century, 160p,

Alan Review

One of a series of books on contemporary topics of interest, this is an excellent one which thoroughly examines both sides of the gun control issue for young adults age 12 and up. Useful information is presented, including the history of gun use from frontier times to the present in the United States, and an explanation of our constitutional right to bear arms. The author also discusses the legal issues surrounding this right, and tracks the development of gun control legislation that has both been proposed and passed into law. A comparison of gun control laws in other countries, such as Great Britain, Japan, Canada, and Brazil, is provided so readers can judge the influence of culture on such legal traditions. Gun safety education is emphasized and positions for and against gun control are fairly argued and supported with documented detail. This book has an excellent set of source notes for each chapter, plus suggested additional readings. 2002, Twenty First Century Books, 160 pp., Thompson

School Library Journal