Inside the Vatican: The Politics and Organization of the Catholic Church
- Book Review,
by Thomas J. Reese
From Publishers Weekly
In his exhaustive treatment of the world's most complex religious organization, Reese, a Jesuit priest who has written about the U.S. Catholic hierarchy (Archbishop: Inside the Power Structure of the American Catholic Church, Harper San Francisco) approaches his subject from a sympathetic yet critical perspective and manages to accomplish two tasks. He describes what is, based on more than 100 interviews with Vatican insiders, and he prescribes what might be, based on his own sense of the church's place in the contemporary world. Though he avoids discussing personal lives of curial officials, he humanizes a vast bureaucracy with an occasional bit of gossip and a few revealing Vatican jokes. For example, one official offered a careerist's recipe for survival in the Roman curia: "Don't think. If you think, don't speak. If you speak, don't write. If you think and if you speak, don't write. If you think and speak and write, don't sign your name. If you think and speak and write and sign your name, don't be surprised." Reese's detailed account of what goes on inside a papal conclave will greatly simplify the work of journalists and teachers during the election of the next pope. Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
One need not be Catholic or even religious to appreciate this fascinating look into the Vatican, an institution with worldwide influence. Reese, a Jesuit priest and political scientist, provides detailed information, much of which is not available elsewhere, on the internal workings of the Vatican both as city-state and the headquarters of the Roman Catholic Church. That information ranges from how popes are elected and how each of the Vatican offices operates to how the Vatican bank functions and what sort of fire department the Vatican has. Reese also offers insights, e.g., that Cardinals tend to elect an older pope to avoid a long reign, and notes procedures for deposing an insane or otherwise incapacitated pope. With its wealth of information, historical background, and analysis, Reese's work should be an important addition for a variety of libraries. [For another view on this subject, see Carl Bernstein's recently released His Holiness John Paul II and the Hidden History of Our Time, which was unavailable for review.]?John Moryl, Yeshiva Univ. Lib., New Yor.-?John Moryl, Yeshiva Univ. Lib., New YorkCopyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
The New York Times Book Review, The Reverend Richard John Neuhaus
Thomas J. Reese, an American Jesuit, offers neither conspiracy theories nor personal tittle-tattle but a detailed--sometimes excruciatingly detailed--account of the day-to-day operation of the offices . . . making up the Roman Curia, which assists the Pope in the administration of the Roman Catholic Church. He writes not as a theologian or historian, and certainly not as a storyteller, but as a social scientist analyzing the management practices of a small but complex bureaucracy . . . a useful antidote to the intrigues and conspiracies spun by more scintillating books.
From Booklist
Given the size, longevity, and worldwide impact of the Roman Catholic Church, a study of its politics and organization is certainly justified; and Reese, a Jesuit trained in political science, is eminently qualified to write it. Although the proliferation of detail may prove daunting to general readers, Reese communicates it in an engaging style that moves easily between gossip (in the best sense of the word) and academic formality. Readers who persevere through the detail will find the account entertaining as well as informative--with much to offer toward understanding not only the Roman Catholic Church but also other global, transnational organizations that play increasingly significant roles in contemporary politics, both global and local. Steve Schroeder
Buy from Amazon
Compare Prices
|
|
Home
